** Please do not copy photos to other websites, including Facebook - post a link instead **

Tal-Ħandaq Nostalgia

Memories of the Royal Naval School, Malta, 1947 - 1978.

Sliema 1882

With neo-classical Police Station.
Quiz Question: From where was this taken?

kg6gort~0.jpg bofors~0.jpg sl1882w~0.jpg evic~0.jpg everdala~0.jpg
Rate this file (No vote yet)

Comment 1 to 10 of 10
Page: 1

Prefect   [Aug 29, 2010 at 02:48 AM]
Next quiz question is - From where was this photo taken?
Martin Powell   [Aug 29, 2010 at 05:19 PM]
A tethered balloon in Valetta? St Paul's steeple? A ship's mast moored across the harbour at/near the ferry landing?
Chris Willmann   [Aug 29, 2010 at 05:45 PM]
I would agree with you Martin St Paul's Steeple. BUT, someone had a damn good lens (telephoto). Is that the Stella Maris Church without the Steeples on the right hand side?
Prefect   [Aug 30, 2010 at 01:37 AM]
Yes thats Stella Maris, History here. I favour the balloon theory but from closer than Valletta unless they had better lenses than we might think. Ship's mast would have to be right in the creek.
Martin Powell   [Aug 30, 2010 at 06:28 PM]
I'm sure they had good lenses - Zeiss's first was 1890, Nikkon's in 1881. And the original picture would have been a dry plate at that time, so much larger than roll film (1889 - Kodak). Don't think a telephoto is needed but according to Wiki they were invented in 1611, 1834, 1860, 1883 and 1891 depending on who you favour. I wonder if the whisky was Army & Navy brand? (What's he on about? - see Wiki on telephotos and HERE )
Prefect   [Aug 31, 2010 at 02:10 AM]
Your link doesn't work. (Now fixed- too many https). Even so, there is the angle of dangle to be considered. St Paul's spire is 200 feet (above street?) and is 5 cables (3000 feet) from the Ferry. I'm sure someone can do the trig but even if you could get to the top, (I've been inside and played the carillon), it doesnt seem high enough for this view.
Martin Powell   [Aug 31, 2010 at 10:44 AM]
Thank you. Research on balloons someone...!!
Chris Willmann   [Sep 01, 2010 at 03:11 PM]
More support for the St Paul's Steeple argument: Google maps shows ground level for Stella Maris and St Paul's to be equal- thus roughly at eye level at ground level and at steeple level- which is what the picture suggests. A little surprised though, that one doesn't catch a bit of Manoel Island..
Martin Powell   [Sep 01, 2010 at 05:13 PM]
I prefer the balloon - 1000 feet is possible - see THIS. And I feel we're a bit higher than Stella Maris. No time for more right now - just off to Malta!!

Update 22 Sept. Having now studied St Paul's from a bit closer, there are 'windows' in the spire, the highest about 30ft from the very top. They face the Strand exactly as in the photo. Chris W doesn't think that the balloon theory fits, as the pic pre-dates the RE balloon corps proper. I suppose we'll never know the verdict on the latest TH Balloon Debate.
Chris Willmann   [Sep 21, 2010 at 07:03 PM]
The other thing came to mind was that a balloon would be quite unstable and blowing in the wind. Given that exposure times were quite lengthy and the camera bulky, it would seem improbable for the picture to be taken from a balloon.

Comment 1 to 10 of 10
Page: 1

Add your comment
Anonymous comments are not allowed here. Log in to post your comment